Home  /  Blog  /  Corporate & Commercial

Corporate & Commercial

Delaware or California? Choosing Where to Incorporate, and Where the S Corp Fits In

One of the first questions founders ask is whether to incorporate in Delaware or California, and whether they should be an “S corp.” The answer depends on where you operate, who owns the company, and whether you plan to raise outside investment.

First, a common misconception: an S corp is not a state

“S corporation” is a federal tax classification, not a type of company you form in a particular state. You first form a corporation (in Delaware, California, or elsewhere) and then, if you qualify, elect S status with the IRS by filing Form 2553. So the real questions are separate: where to incorporate, and how the company should be taxed.

To qualify for S status, a corporation generally must have no more than 100 shareholders, all of whom are individuals (or certain trusts and estates) who are U.S. citizens or residents, and only one class of stock. Differences in voting rights are allowed, but every share must carry the same economic rights. That last rule matters a great deal, as you will see below.

Why companies choose Delaware

Delaware is the most popular state of incorporation for a reason. Its corporate law is highly developed, its Court of Chancery specializes in business disputes, and investors and their lawyers are deeply familiar with it. If you plan to raise venture capital, most institutional investors will expect a Delaware C corporation. Venture investors typically receive preferred stock, and preferred stock is a second class of stock, which is not permitted for an S corporation.

Delaware also carries its own annual obligations. Every Delaware corporation must file an annual report and pay Delaware franchise tax by March 1 each year, whether or not it does any business in Delaware. The annual report fee is $50, and the franchise tax minimum is $175 under the authorized shares method or $400 under the assumed par value capital method. You will also need a registered agent in Delaware.

The catch for California businesses

If your company operates in California, incorporating in Delaware does not take you out of California’s system. A Delaware corporation doing business here must register with the California Secretary of State as a foreign corporation, and every corporation that is incorporated, registered, or doing business in California owes California’s $800 minimum franchise tax. In practice, a California-based Delaware company pays both states.

California also taxes the company’s income regardless of where it is incorporated. An S corporation pays the greater of 1.5% of its net income or the $800 minimum. A C corporation pays California’s corporate rate on its California income.

There is one more wrinkle. Under California Corporations Code section 2115, an out-of-state private corporation that does more than half of its business in California and has more than half of its voting shares held by people with California addresses can be treated as a “quasi-California” corporation, and certain California corporate law provisions may apply to it anyway. Delaware and California courts have not always agreed on how far that reaches, which is one reason the analysis should be done carefully.

A practical way to decide

  • A California business owned by a small group of Californians, with no plans for institutional investment: a California corporation is often the simpler and less expensive choice, and it can elect S status if it qualifies.
  • A startup planning to raise venture capital, or with investors who expect it: a Delaware C corporation is usually the expected structure, and the added cost is part of doing business with those investors.
  • A company with operations or owners in several states: Delaware’s predictability can be worth the additional filings, but the tax picture in each state where you operate should be reviewed first.

Many small businesses are also well served by a limited liability company, which can elect to be taxed as an S corporation as well. The right answer depends on your ownership, your growth plans, and your tax position, and it is worth coordinating with your CPA before you file anything.

How S.E. Law can help

S.E. Law advises founders and established companies on entity selection, formation, ownership structure, and governance, so the business is built on the right foundation from the start. If you are weighing Delaware against California, or considering an S election, we are happy to talk it through.

Shirin Ehyaei, Esq.

Shirin Ehyaei, Esq. is the founder of S.E. Law, PC, a California firm advising companies, founders, and individuals in business matters, litigation, and personal injury. Full bio.

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading it or contacting S.E. Law does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change, and the right approach depends on the specific facts of your situation.

Contact Us

Begin a conversation.

For private inquiries and confidential consultations, please contact the firm directly.

Submit an Inquiry (310) 739-0865